Submitted by Tina from Athens, GA
I've always been turned on watching threesomes in porn, so I decided to plan one to surprise my boyfriend. The girl was my friend's girlfriend, a college student, a bit younger than all of us. I think she may be bi because she has always been very flirty with me. One day while drinking at my house, I told her I wanted to surprise my guy with a threesome. She was all for it. The next day, she came over to hang out. I was nervous and giddy. When my BF went into the kitchen, she and I started to kiss so he'd see it when he came out.
He came back into the living room and started laughing. But that laugh went away when we both stood up and went to him. I started kissing him while she started undressing him. We then led him into the bedroom and told him to get on the bed.
She and I went down on him, me taking his cock into my mouth, her licking his balls. He clearly was enjoying this, but then she kept kissing me. That's when I just felt like--she was more interested in me than him. But we kept going and soon we were all naked. I wasn't comfortable yet so I didn't want him to go down on her. She kept trying to touch me and put her fingers inside me. It went really fast from there and that's where I think we screwed up. We should have taken our time. My BF is very well-endowed, almost too big. He told me to get on his face, and asked if she wanted to get on top of him.
So I straddled his face, facing away from her. I could feel her ready herself, climbing on top of him. He starts to lick me, and then he stopped. In hindsight it was probably only a few seconds but in the moment it felt like a long time, and I got upset. I got off, and laid beside them. Thinking I just wanted to watch--she started pumping on him hard. It just got me more upset. Couldn't they tell I was bothered?
I left the room and went into the bathroom. He came after me. She left. We talked about it and I told him I was upset because he was so enthralled with her that he stopped doing anything to me. That's when he explained that it was only a few seconds because it actually was uncomfortable when she climbed on top of him. She was very petite. He's huge. It was a tight fit. LOL I should have known this. It was a lesson learned for sure! Unfortunately, we never did anything like that again. It wasn't until many years later that I found someone who wanted to do this with me and I have found I rather enjoy watching than participating.
Submitted by listeners. These are not fantasies, but real stories from real people, but not using real names. Some have also submitted real pictures, available to our members. Have a confession? Tell us your secrets here.